42 Agency
Resources → ABM Campaign → Play Design

ABM Play Design: Creating Effective Plays by Tier

How to design coordinated campaign plays that match your account tiers and buying stage.

An ABM "play" is a coordinated set of tactics designed to engage and advance specific accounts. Plays combine channels, content, and timing into a repeatable motion.

Different account tiers require different play intensity. Tier 1 gets white-glove treatment. Tier 3 gets smart automation.

The Three ABM Approaches

Approach Tier Personalization Scale
1:1 Tier 1 Fully custom per account 25-50 accounts
1:Few Tier 2 Customized per cluster 100-300 accounts
1:Many Tier 3 Personalized at scale 500-1,000 accounts

Tier 1: 1:1 Plays

Tier 1

Tier 1 accounts justify significant investment. Each play should feel like a campaign built just for that account.

Example Play: Executive Engagement

  • Custom research report on their industry/company
  • Personalized video from your executive to their executive
  • LinkedIn engagement from multiple team members
  • Direct mail package to key stakeholders
  • Custom landing page with account-specific content
  • SDR outreach referencing the above touchpoints

Tier 1 Channel Mix

  • Direct mail: High-value, personalized packages
  • 1:1 ads: LinkedIn/display ads targeting specific company
  • Executive engagement: Your leaders reaching out to theirs
  • Custom content: Reports, videos, microsites built for the account
  • Events: Exclusive dinners, executive roundtables

Tier 2: 1:Few Plays

Tier 2

Group accounts into clusters by shared attributes (industry, use case, challenge), then create plays for each cluster.

Example Play: Industry Cluster Campaign

  • Industry-specific content hub (guide, webinar, case study)
  • LinkedIn ads targeting accounts in the cluster
  • Email sequence with industry-specific messaging
  • SDR outreach using industry talking points
  • Virtual event (industry roundtable, panel)

Cluster Examples

  • By industry: FinTech cluster, HealthTech cluster, eCommerce cluster
  • By use case: "Replacing legacy system" cluster, "Scaling operations" cluster
  • By trigger: "Recently funded" cluster, "New leadership" cluster

Tier 3: 1:Many Plays

Tier 3

Tier 3 uses programmatic tactics that scale, with personalization through tokens and dynamic content.

Example Play: Intent-Triggered Nurture

  • LinkedIn ads targeting all Tier 3 accounts
  • Dynamic email with company name/industry personalization
  • Automated SDR sequence when intent spikes
  • Retargeting based on website engagement
  • Scaled direct mail for accounts showing engagement

Tier 3 Personalization at Scale

  • Dynamic content: Emails/pages that change based on industry, company size
  • Intent-based triggers: Escalate from Tier 3 to Tier 2 tactics when signals spike
  • Programmatic ads: LinkedIn/display targeting all accounts with relevant content
The Graduation Path

Tier 3 isn't a dead end. When a Tier 3 account shows strong engagement or intent, graduate them to Tier 2. When a Tier 2 account requests a demo or shows executive engagement, graduate to Tier 1 treatment.

Play Components Checklist

Every play should define:

  • Trigger: What starts this play? (Intent spike, form fill, sales request)
  • Target: Who specifically? (Account tier, personas, buying stage)
  • Tactics: What channels and content? (Ads, email, direct mail, etc.)
  • Timing: What's the sequence and duration?
  • Transition: What's the success criteria to move to next stage?
  • Owner: Who orchestrates this play?

Channel Selection by Tier

Channel Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3
Custom content ✅ Per account ✅ Per cluster ❌
Direct mail ✅ Premium ✅ Scaled ⚠️ Triggered only
LinkedIn Ads ✅ 1:1 targeting ✅ Cluster targeting ✅ List targeting
Email ✅ 1:1 personalized ✅ Cluster personalized ✅ Dynamic tokens
Events ✅ Exclusive ✅ Industry-specific ✅ Webinars
SDR outreach ✅ Highly researched ✅ Cluster talking points ⚠️ Intent-triggered

Get the ABM Campaign Template

Play templates for each tier, channel planning worksheets, and campaign calendars.

Download Template →

Key Takeaways

  • Match play intensity to account tier—don't over-invest in Tier 3
  • 1:1 = custom everything; 1:Few = cluster-based; 1:Many = programmatic
  • Every play needs a trigger, target, tactics, timing, and transition criteria
  • Build graduation paths so accounts can move up tiers based on engagement
  • Document plays in templates so they're repeatable